Skip to content

Who won the Trump-Biden debate? One thing is certain, ‘it was hard to watch,’ political experts say

The Trump-Biden debate “cemented” the “none of the above” sentiment across the U.S., says Costas Panagopoulos, head of Northeastern’s political science department.

Former President Trump and President Biden stand in front of podiums in front of a bright blue, red background with red and blue text: "Presidential Debate."
The Trump-Biden debate cemented the “none of the above” sentiment across the U.S., says Costas Panagopoulos, a Northeastern political scientist. Photo by Justin Sullivan/Getty Images

President Joe Biden — his voice low and hoarse — stumbled through 90 minutes of his tightly controlled debate with former President Donald Trump, speaking rapidly and at times losing his train of thought.

While Biden, 81, appeared inarticulate at times, Trump, 78, dodged questions and spewed falsehoods with little opposition, says Costas Panagopoulos, head of Northeastern University’s political science department. 

The first presidential debate of the 2024 election took place according to new rules — muted microphones, no studio audience, no opening statements and two commercial breaks — which contributed to virtually no cross-talk or interruptions as the candidates answered questions.

Panagopoulos says neither candidate was particularly persuasive, a reflection of the low expectations for the clash — and the mood of the country.

“This debate will only cement the ‘none of the above’ sentiment across the country,” he says. 

“In debates, style can matter as much as substance,” Panagopoulos says. “Overall, it was hard to watch. Both candidates fell short, for different reasons.”

The proposed format for the debate was a departure from the norm in debates past. Neither candidate was allowed props or notes, only a pen, paper and water. The debate took place at CNN’s Atlanta headquarters. CNN anchors Jake Tapper and Dana Bash co-moderated.

“It sounded like Biden had a cold and, perhaps as a result, was sometimes incoherent, especially early in the debate,” Northeastern University political scientist Nick Beauchamp says. “Trump was also incoherent, jumping from thought to thought and frequently telling falsehoods.”

Beauchamp continues: “Both clearly detest the other, and both kept gravitating to insults and bombast rather than substance and policy. I’d say this was the worst presidential debate I’ve seen. It improved a bit in the second half, though even then there were many low-lights, such as the golf exchange.”

The last time a presidential debate was held absent a studio audience was in 1960, when the first televised debate between two candidates took place between John F. Kennedy and Richard Nixon.

The topic of abortion prompted the first several jabs. 

Northeastern Global News, in your inbox.

Sign up for NGN’s daily newsletter for news, discovery and analysis from around the world.